What Happens If I Use the Wrong Type of Oil for My Car?

You change your oil to keep your engine healthy—but what happens if I use the wrong type of oil for my car? At first, it might not seem like a big deal. Yet beneath the surface, the wrong one can quietly impact performance, efficiency, and even long-term reliability. The real effects may surprise you—and knowing them could save your engine.

Time for an oil change in Brooklyn? Contact us for expert service!

TL;DR

Using the wrong oil may seem minor, but it can harm your engine over time. It reduces performance and fuel efficiency, increases friction and wear, delays lubrication, and risks overheating. Poor oil choice also raises emissions, damages aftertreatment systems, and can even void your warranty if it doesn’t meet manufacturer specifications. Always follow your owner’s manual to ensure proper protection, efficiency, and long-term engine reliability.

How Does Using the Wrong Oil Impact Your Car’s Engine?

Engine oil isn’t just a fluid—it performs many critical functions. It lubricates moving parts to reduce friction, helps cool the engine, keeps deposits from building up, protects against corrosion, maintains hydraulic pressure for systems like variable valve timing, and even assists in sealing.

When the wrong oil is used—whether it’s the wrong viscosity, grade, specification, or additive package—these functions can be compromised. At first, the effects may seem mild, but over time the consequences build. Poor lubrication can increase wear, incorrect viscosity can disrupt hydraulic systems, and weak additives may allow sludge or corrosion to develop.

The result is a gradual decline in performance, reduced efficiency, and eventually, engine damage or failure. Sticking to the one recommended by your vehicle’s manufacturer ensures all of these protective roles are carried out effectively.

Reduced Engine Performance and Efficiency

The wrong viscosity or specification can quietly rob your car of power and fuel economy. Instead of running smoothly, the engine has to work harder, loses responsiveness, and wastes energy. Here are the main reasons why:

• Increased frictional losses: Thicker ones resists flow, making the engine expend more effort to pump and move parts. Too-thin oil may fail to maintain a protective film, causing internal rubbing. Tests show switching from 5W-30 to 0W-20 reduced friction torque by ~5.6 Nm, cut losses by 11–12%, and improved fuel economy by ~2.1%.
  
• Slower cold starts and warm-ups: Thick oil flows sluggishly in cold conditions, delaying lubrication and reducing performance until it warms up properly.
  
• Hydraulic system issues: Engines with systems like variable valve timing rely on precise oil pressure and flow. The wrong one can reduce responsiveness, power, and smooth operation.

Increased Wear and Tear on Engine Components

Using the wrong one doesn’t just affect performance—it can also speed up mechanical wear inside your engine. Over time, this leads to costly damage and shorter engine life. Key contributing factors include:

• Insufficient film strength: If it is too thin under high load or temperature, it fails to maintain a protective layer. Bearings, cylinder walls, and piston rings can suffer direct contact and premature wear.
  
• Delayed lubrication at cold starts: Thick oil in cold conditions circulates too slowly. In those first seconds after startup, metal parts rub without proper lubrication, causing gradual damage over repeated cycles.
  
• Additive mismatch or absence: Modern oils rely on additives like anti-wear agents, detergents, and antioxidants. Using it with the wrong or missing package can lead to deposit buildup, faster oxidation, and increased surface wear.
  
• High temperature and shear stress: At high RPMs or loads, oil faces extreme heat and pressure. If the oil’s high-temperature high shear (HTHS) viscosity is too low or degrades quickly, protective strength is lost and wear accelerates.

Risk of Overheating and Engine Damage

This fluid does more than reduce friction—it also helps remove heat from vital components such as bearings, piston crowns, and turbochargers. When the wrong one is used, its ability to cool and protect the engine can be compromised, raising the risk of overheating and serious damage.

Poor Fuel Economy and Higher Emissions

Using the wrong one doesn’t just harm your engine—it can also reduce efficiency and increase your car’s environmental impact. Several factors contribute to this outcome:

• Increased internal resistance: Thicker oils or those not optimized for the engine’s design create more drag, forcing the engine to burn more fuel to produce the same power.
  
• Slower warm-up: If it delays the engine from reaching optimal temperature, it runs less efficiently for longer, burning extra fuel and releasing more pollutants.
  
• Combustion inefficiencies: Also helps with sealing and friction control. If the wrong oil allows leaks or blow-by, combustion becomes less efficient, raising hydrocarbon (HC) emissions.
  
• Impact on aftertreatment systems: Modern engines rely on systems like catalytic converters or diesel particulate filters. Oils with the wrong additive content (e.g., too much ash, phosphorus, or sulfur) can damage these systems, leading to higher emissions and possible failure to meet regulatory standards.

Voiding Your Car’s Warranty

Using the wrong one can put your car’s warranty at risk, especially if it doesn’t meet the requirements outlined by the manufacturer. Your owner’s manual specifies the approved viscosities, service categories (API, ACEA, or OEM standards), and in some cases, proprietary approvals. Straying from these can be considered a failure to follow prescribed maintenance.

If a component fails and the manufacturer inspects the vehicle, they may deny warranty coverage if the issue is linked to the use of the wrong oil—whether due to incorrect viscosity, missing specifications, or incompatible additives. In such cases, the burden of proof often falls on the manufacturer to show the oil choice directly caused the damage.

That said, it’s not usually the brand of fluid that matters, but whether it meets the required specifications. Using a different brand is acceptable if it meets the proper standards. Additionally, in some regions, consumer protection laws prevent manufacturers from voiding warranties solely because non-OEM fluids were used—unless it can be proven that the fluid directly caused the damage.

Key Takeaways

1. Engine oil has many roles: It lubricates, cools, cleans, protects, maintains hydraulic systems, and seals. Using the wrong oil compromises these functions, leading to performance loss, efficiency issues, and eventual engine damage.
   
2. Reduced performance and efficiency: Wrong viscosity increases friction, slows cold starts, and disrupts hydraulic systems. This results in less power, slower response, and higher fuel consumption.
   
3. Increased wear and tear: Thin oil under heat or load weakens protection, while thick oil delays lubrication during cold starts. Missing or mismatched additives and poor high-temperature stability accelerate component wear.
   
4. Overheating risks: Wrong oil can reduce cooling, generate more heat through friction, and break down under stress. This may cause sludge, varnish, or even severe thermal damage like warped heads, piston failure, or engine seizure.
   
5. Fuel economy and emissions: Thick or unsuitable oil creates more drag, slows warm-up, causes combustion inefficiencies, and can damage catalytic converters or diesel particulate filters—leading to higher fuel use and emissions.
   
6. Warranty concerns: Using oil that doesn’t meet manufacturer specs can void warranty coverage if it causes damage. Brand is less important than meeting viscosity and certification standards, though consumer protection laws may apply in some regions.